Kovar Capital: What Should I Do With My Old 401(k)?


Hey Taylor - I just left my old company because it was forced to downsize. Fortunately, another opportunity came around at just the right time, but I’m wondering what to do with my 401(k). Do I leave it with my old employer or move it over to my new company’s plan? - Nena

Hey Nena - Happy to hear the job situation worked out! These are tough times for so many, and it’s nice to hear good news about people staying employed.

401(k)s are tricky, and your situation shines a light on some of the reasons why. I’m going to give a broader assessment of these accounts to help clarify my point, but I promise I’ll finish up by answering your question.

Problems with 401(k)s. As far as retirement accounts go, these are not my favorites. The main reasons are that there are too many fees and they’re limiting as far as what positions you can hold. You also need to make sure you’ve worked the requisite years to have 100 percent of matched funds vested, and if your company closes or files bankruptcy before that time, you might lose money by no fault of your own. Because of these factors, and all things being equal, I’d say an IRA is a better choice.

Benefit of the employee match. To contradict the above paragraph, if you have an employer matching up to three to five percent of your contribution and you have every intention of staying with that company long enough to become entirely vested, that’s a nice way to pad your retirement account. If you’re able to fund a 401(k) through pre-tax contributions and then still add money to an IRA, even better. It’s not free money because you have to stick around to earn it, but for those who do stick around, the payments are very real.

What to do when you leave. Finally, back to your question. There’s no good reason to leave your 401(k) at your old job, and there’s not a particularly good reason to roll it over to your new company. Even if you now have an employer you love with a matching program, you can still take that money while turning the old 401(k) into an IRA with better investment options. A 401(k) is a great way to get your retirement funds started, but it’s far from the pinnacle of investing.

Whatever you choose, make sure to fund that retirement account as much as possible. Congrats on the new job and good luck! 


No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here