Gray County Candidate Forum, Part 2: Question and Answer

Posted

After the introductions portion of the Gray County candidate forum came the question and answer portion, and are as follows:

Question #1 for the Sheriff candidates:

Have either of you, or the Pampa Police Department, or the Sheriff’s Office been instructed not to arrest elected officials or family members?

Dallas Cline: “I’ve never been instructed to do that by anybody ever. So the answer is no, it’s never happened.”

JC Skinner: “Same sentiment. The answer is no, I’ve never been instructed nor has anyone in my agency ever been instructed to do that.”

Question #2 for the Sheriff and County Judge candidates:

Seems like everything is about Pampa and not Gray County, from patrols to emergency, nothing for Lefors or McLean. How do you plan to change this?

Chris Porter: “The role of the County Judge is not to make the patrols. There’s been a lot of controversy over this. I know that we try to cover the county as well as possible. I think we are limited on resources at times. We are trying to be smart with our tax rate. There’s been a lot of talk about first responders and things of that nature. When I came into office, we had a shamble of ambulance services. But we went ahead and made a local agreement that got us through the pandemic, we couldn’t have done it without it. Our volunteer fire departments were barely hanging on at $10,000 a year, and the commissioners court increased it to $45,000 a year. Our Sheriff’s Department was driving around in vehicles that weren’t dependable and sometimes broke down during response to calls and they have 900 square miles to cover, so the commissioners court made sure we invested into that heavily, and we made sure that everyone is safe so we can get where we need to go. I hate the vitriol of these local elections, that’s not what we’re about. If someone wants to run against someone, they should be allowed to because they want to do the same thing the person in office is doing. They want to make sure they’re doing the best job possible for everyone in this room. I hate this because our Sheriff’s Department and our Police Department have always worked well together and they always have our backs. I’m hoping we can repair all of this. But the County Judge has no real responsibility in setting the patrols up, we just provide what the Sheriff’s Office has asked, and we have done that with every single request so far.” (Chris later corrected his statement regarding the Volunteer Fire Department fund increase. The departments were at $35,000 and were increased by $10,000, totaling $45,000 per department for all three, and have not been reduced under Chris’s tenure as County Judge.)

Rick Amerson: “I don’t have a lot of experience, but I’ve talked to many people in the county and in the city, so I’m beginning to see what is there. People that I’ve had working for me in the past seldom do I have this kind of thing, but if I do, I would want to fix it. So what is the problem? I’ve been talking to different folks in the county and I’ve talked to the Hoover Fire Department and the Pampa Fire Department, they’re all part of the county. But the people out there in McLean and Lefors are part of the county too. I understand that there is senior center has a luncheon on Thursdays in Lefors and I went there and they were closed. I can’t find anyone that knows about it, so if you know someone, come tell me what I need to do to talk to someone.”

Steve Barton: “First I want to say to the two guys that are running. There hasn’t been anything going between us, and I appreciate that. The police officers and sheriffs that I know, I know they are working hard. The sheriffs work to get out to Lefors and McLean. The resources are limited, there is only so much that can be done with what they have. But would I like to see that increase? Of course, but our sheriffs are out there working. Short of having someone move out to McLean and live there, that makes it where if they’re living here, they have to go out to McLean, there is going to be longer response times. Having gone and talked to the Hoover Fire Department, I know what there funds are. They have nine trucks in their budget, and they’re old. There’s only so much resources, so we do need to help those people who live outside of Pampa because it is a massive importance that the roads are maintained as we have all this construction, and as we have all these good things that happen for Pampa, it also needs to happen for Gray County and it can’t just be for Pampa. Whether that’s increasing the sheriff patrols, but the judge has nothing to do with that, zero. He doesn’t tell them where to go, that’s where the sheriff comes in to make the decisions, and we need to tell the Hoover Volunteer Fire Department and the Lefors Volunteer Fire Department and the McLean guys that Gray County has their backs as well.”

Dallas Cline: “With 900 square miles, we need deputies to go further out to Lefors and McLean. Our population centers around Lefors, Pampa and McLean, so that’s where the deputies need to be at. I know there’s going to be calls out somewhere else, but when you have three deputies sitting at the Sheriff’s Office and it takes 45 minutes to get to a domestic in McLean, that’s a problem. I’ve seen it. I don’t think they’re being managed properly and that’s what I plan to do, is have some leadership and have these deputies out where they’re supposed to be.”

JC Skinner: “I’ve increased those patrols. I think you can ask the citizens of McLean and anywhere that they’ve seen our deputies. Yes we have 900 square miles as mentioned, but with three people working, you have one person in McLean by themselves and they get a two-man call, now they have to wait for backup. So we have to allocate our resources as we can, and I do believe that the presence has been increased over there and we have two deputies that actually live within ten miles of McLean that are on call when a major event happens.”

Question #3 for the Sheriff candidates:

How do you describe the relationship between the Sheriff’s Office and the Police Department, and what will you change if elected?

JC Skinner: “I do think we have a fine relationship with the Police Department. There are things we don’t agree on and I don’t always expect us to agree with one another on what their agency is doing-I don’t control what they’re doing and they don’t control what we’re doing, however when something happens when they need help, we help and they’re there for us, and we always have each other’s backs. I feel like our relationship is fine.”

Dallas Cline: “Historically, Sheriff’s offices and police officers have always had a bit of tension. I think that our Chief of Police works really hard to maintain a good relationship, and I do know that him and JC get along. I think things could be better, I know they can be better, and I think we can build on that. We can do training together. Some of this stuff we don’t do together, and going and talking to Hoover, they would like to be included in some of it too, especially when it comes to alert training because we’re all going to be here when something bad happens, in the city and the county. I think we have a good relationship and we can build on that.”

Question #4 for the Sheriff candidates:

Can you give us a brief explanation of the Sheriff’s Office budget?

JC Skinner: “The Sheriff’s Office budget is nearly $5 million yearly between the jail and Sheriff’s Office adminstrative side. It’s two different budgets running together. Everything we have comes out of those budgets, and if you go over on certain line items, you have to see where you can cut another line item to even out those costs. I’ve been doing the budget for about five years and during that time we have not gone over.”

Dallas Cline: “I have not run the Sheriff’s Office budget, but I have looked at it online and I do know how to add and subtract. Anybody with a high school education can run a budget. The last time I checked I have a Bachelor’s Degree in Criminal Justice and am working on a Master’s Degree, so I think I’m well-qualified to run a budget.”

Question #5 for the County Judge candidates:

What do you expect the data center to do for the county, ISD, and the city?

Chris Porter: “The value of the data center is $3 billion, and taxable value is about $6 million, and it’s going to double in value. There’s been a lot controversy over tax abatements. Tax abatements are there to stablize the county tax rate to make sure we don’t have a huge initial evaluation when it’s built and then ten years later, the depreciation happens. In order to keep that off of a roller coaster ride, we agreed to a tax abatement. The schools will be fully funded on Prop B. I know some of you voted for it and some of you didn’t, but Prop B will be fully funded from this. Not only that, but we had negotiations with Google and we talked about all the campuses in Gray County, including McLean and Lefors and Grandview Hopkins were given the access to Google classes. We negotiated hard not just for the county, but for the school district. Our city is about to see a boom in sales tax like we have not seen in decades. There’s an estimated 2,500 workers that will come in, they will be pouring concrete in the next couple of days. This thing should be fully operational by 2027. This is not only project that is interested in Gray County. We have multiple projects that are interested that we are talking to right now and it starts in my office. I think it’s a great thing for the county, for the school district, for the population, but I think it’s the best thing for our children. They will have jobs that pay well and it’s guaranteed with the tax abatement. It guarantees jobs and it guarantees it’s air-cooled.”

Rick Amerson: “So where we are right now is bringing in a lot of construction, thousands of construction workers. I’ve looked at the Gray County Population and it’s around 21,000, about 17,000 are in Pampa, so that’s about 4,000 in the rest of the county, and we are going to be coming close to what I’ve heard is 4-6,000 by the time they get done. For the city, the sales taxes should be pretty high. Walmart will be doing really well, and CVS and some of those places because those guys have to shop some place. But the county is not collecting that so we will have a problem with how we handle it because the people are in the county and the revenue is all in the city. I’ve talked to the sheriff about how they will be able to handle no more coming into their budget, and we don’t know the answer. That’s something I will have to look at and try to fix it. Another thing is talking with Google and all the things that happened were done behind closed doors. I can’t tell you what went on, but I can tell you the kinds of things that I’ve done as I mentioned earlier. We can work with Google and bring them in here, and not just Google, but Apple both have announced they are moving their operations to Austin when we can bring them in here and work with them.”

Steve Barton: “The great thing about having industry come in to Pampa, we haven’t had industry come in since Celanese left. It’s huge that we now have Google coming into our community and County to give us tax dollars. It’s going to be huge for our schools, our city and our county. They just gave a $100,000 grant to our schools to help build the CTE center. That means our students will be trained to go to work at the data center. They come out of high school and they have a job. That’s a huge benefit to this. That also means we will have the tax dollars to help the Sheriff’s Department. We have the tax dollars to help the Police Department, our Fire Departments and Volunteer Fire Departments. These tax dollars will be essential and if we manage it right, no one’s taxes are going to go up. This is a great thing for Gray County. It needs to be managed properly like anything else. You look at it and think, ‘wow, we have all of these that are going to come in. They’re going to eat at our restaurants, they’re going to get their hair cut here, they’re going to put money into our accounts, they’re going to shop at our stores, they’re going to put money into our community.’ Whether those in construction stay or leave, we know what’s going to happen, and take advantange of it. We know they’re going to bring families in and we will see the school improve. As a teacher, I can tell you right now my windows in my classroom-when the wind blows from the south, the curtains move. That’s not an exaggeration. I have no AC right now. When it’s warm, I only have one working window. These are things these new industries can come in and fix and help our community. I know there are some growing pains and I know not everybody is going to be great with it, but we need to look at the bigger picture, and the bigger picture is this is good for our community.

Question #6 for the County Judge candidates:

What is your stance on tax abatements?

Steve Barton: “It’s one of those necessary evils. You have to have a tax abatements to bring these companies in. You have to say, ‘we have to give you a break to get you into the community,’ but if one guy is giving 100% and another guy is giving zero, and if we run these guys off, we’re still at zero. At least now we will get some in, and this is good. If we don’t bring these companies in, they’re not going to say, ‘well, we’re just not going to create business then.’ They will go to some other county and give their tax dollars to someone else. We need industry in Gray County, and our current leadership has done a good job. I think it could be done better, but they have done a good job. We are going to see growth. Things are going good in Gray County. Those who have been here a long time know things have been tough. Pampa has been hanging on since Celanese left. My wife’s father worked for Celanese down in Bishop, and we know about when it left this community. I worked in Borger when Phillips changed, it changed the town’s dynamic. Celanese changed Pampa’s dynamic. We have a chance now to fill it back up and put Pampa back where it should be.”

Rick Amerson: “I’ve looked at what we’ve done with tax abatements, and Google is a multi-trillion dollar company with ‘t’, and they’re building a multi-billion dollar project with a ‘b’, and we’re giving them a multi-million dollar tax abatement with an ‘m’, and that’s just insignificant for a company like Google. That’s not the most important thing we should be looking at. If I were working for the county, that’s fine and I would take it, but that’s not what I would want to do. So how do you work with a county, what can they do? We have a lot we can offer in Gray County besides a tax abatement, that’s what everybody else has. We have a lot of stuff here, a lot of good people, and we are working on the schools, and that would be even better for income. The tax abatement is one way if we had to we would, but it’s a done deal. That’s the deal we have now and we have to work with that and move on from there.”

Chris Porter: “I hate tax abatements, don’t like them, don’t want to do them, but it’s a necessary part of this business. We have two data centers that are talking to Gray County who don’t want tax abatements, and it’s because they want to use water. So the commissioners court was able to control the amount of water that will be used for this data center through a tax abatement. If a company comes in and does a $16 billion project which will be five times the size of the one we have right now and they tear up County Road 6, they walk away from it and we get stuck with the bill because we are required to provide them with a road. I appreciate the people who think we are doing a good job, and I think we are doing a good job. We can’t give away what we don’t already have. So a tax abatement paid at $1.6 million a year to the county, we didn’t have it to begin with, and now we have better industry coming in that is stable, dependable, and pays a minimum of $65,000 a year that is guaranteed. They don’t pay it, then they write a check for $40 million. They violated the terms. And I promise you, I will hold them accountable to every single term in the tax abatement. They aren’t the only tax abatement here in Gray County-we have one for Keystone Towers that saved 100 jobs. We have tax abatements with the windmills in the south part of the county, and I had multiple questions about tax abatements. This is a guideline to put up, it’s a guardrail to put up to protect our counties resources. Again, I don’t like them, but it’s a part of business.”

Question #7 for the 223rd District Judge candidates:

What aspects of your legal career have most prepared you to manage the courtoom, difficult rulings, and ensure cases move efficiently and fairly?

Franklin McDonough: “So I’ve had the fortune of practicing law in multiple courts in front of multiple District Judges, so I’ve seen what works and what doesn’t work. Have I not only been a prosecutor, I’ve been a civil attorney. In fact, my first divorce case was against Todd Alvey on the other side. In the civil arena, I fought against a very good CPS appellate judge, in which I had to walk into the Texas Supreme Court with nine justices who when they walk out, everyone’s heart stops. In that decision, it was a 9-0 decision which changed the law in the state of Texas and I can say I’m the one who stood there and argued it. So if you want somebody who knows how to make cases move, then you want somebody who has been in the arena and had to fight the tough cases. I can say that Mark Buzzard gave me a blessing when I went into civil practice and asked me if I would try a car wreck case, and he said, ‘you’ll get poured out in Gray County.’ Fortunately I got to be on that on the plaintiff’s side representing Columbus Morgan and I got him his $11,000 back. So I’ve been in the courtroom, and everything I’ve done in the courtroom has led me to this moment, to know exactly how to move a docket because there’s two districts in this. If you want to see a docket move, start coming to court in January 2027.”

Todd Alvey: “I want to echo what Franklin just said: it’s the experience. I’ve been practicing in the Texas panhandle for 34 years. I started when I was 24 years old. I tried my first jury trial when I was 24 years old. I have practiced in numerous courts-federal, district, county, justice of the peace. I’ve tried cases in numerous courts across the Texas panhandle. I’ve practiced in front of numerous judges in the Texas panhandle. I know how to make things work from experience.”

Question #8 for the 223rd District Judge candidates:

Where do you stand on Sharia Law in Texas, and what action steps are you willing to take to prevent its widespread overreach?

Todd Alvey: “I don’t think that I can comment on anything that may happen in a courtroom because first of all, I don’t think I can ethically, and secondly I don’t know enough about it to do it. Third is we are talking about Gray County-I don’t know if there is a whole lot of Sharia Law exercised in Gray County. So if the law gets passed elsewhere and we have to follow that in the 223rd Judicial District.”
Franklin McDonough: “The Texas Code of Judicial Conduct says I cannot answer that question, because either way that is taking a stance on something I cannot. I will tell you when it comes to the law, I will stand on the law. As DA, everyone in this room has heard about something that I made a decision that was not popular, and I sleep at night knowing this: popular or not, I was made to make the tough decisions. You can be sure when it comes to the law, I will not only follow it, I will follow it whether you like it or not.”

Question #9 for State Representative for District 88 candidate:

Please describe your financial relationship with Texas United for Conservative Majority Tim Dunn and Farris Wilks.

John Browning: “These folks have donated to my campaign. I’m not in a phone call relationship with them, they’re not in my contact list. They have found favor enough to donate to my campain and I’m thankful for that.”

Question #10 for County Judge candidates:

Will you support spot-zoning, and if so, how will you protect homeowners’ values?

Rick Amerson: “I don’t know much about that, so I’ll have to look into it.”

Chris Porter: “There’s been a lot of talk about property rights, and I want you to understand I’m 100% a Constitutionalist. I believe if you own your property, you should be able to do with it however you want to. The problem here is your neighbor. I’m not going to go next door to my neighbor and ask them if it’s okay to sell my house. I’m not going to ask them if it’s okay if paint my house purple. It’s my home, I’ll do what I want to with it. The problem is the neighbors get upset with what they’ve done to profit, because they’re absentee and they don’t live here, but they own the property. If they want to lease it or sell it, they should be allowed to do so. Spot-zoning I believe is illegal in the state of Texas. I am going to do exactly as Mr. McDonough said: I follow the law. There are times I don’t agree with the law, but the law is the law. I don’t believe a woman who is making a decision between Christmas presents and feeding her children should be held accountable for stealing formula. You have to make those decisions. Common sense is the most important thing to me. I was raised on it, I worked hard for a living. So I may not agree with it, but that was the charge. You have to do something with it. Again, I believe spot-zoning is illegal in the state of Texas.”
Steve Barton: “I haven’t given a lot of thought, but teaching government, I firmly believe in the Constitution, and the 5th and 14th Amendment, both saying that the government cannot just come in and take away your land. Whatever the law is, it needs to be followed 100%. There’s really no other way around it. You have your guidelines and whether you like it or not, if the state of Texas says this is how we do it, then that’s how you do it. It’s pretty cut and dry.”

Question #11 for Steve Barton (County Judge):

If you should win the race for County Judge, will you continue your employment with Pampa ISD knowing the position of judge requires a great deal of time to execute properly?
“No, if I am fortunate enough to win this election, I will retire from teaching. At that point, I will have had about 33 years of teaching experience. I could retire now. So if I’m fortunate enough, I will retire, but I will teach next fall because that’s when the Judge will be sworn in in ‘27. That will allow me to actually add another year and then take over as County Judge.”

Question #12 for all Justice of the Peace candidates:

What is your vision on dealing with truancy cases? 

Michael Lewis (Justice of the Peace 1&3): “I spoke to several principals at Pampa ISD and the Superintendent in Lefors and Stuart Smith here at Pampa ISD, and there are some things they like and some things they don’t like, and some things they want to change. My vision is I think working with the kids with behavior issues, a lot of times it’s not just the kids but the parents too, so I want to make sure the kid is held more responsible outside of having to go back to school because they’re escaping school anyway. So whatever I can do within the law to make them stay in school without missing instructional time. If they’re not sitting in class, they’re not learning. But if there are other things I can do within the law to help those kids learn their lesson and stay in school, I want to do that. I don’t just want to slap them on the wrist and tell them to go to school this many hours a day, what is that teaching them? I want to find different ways within the law to keep them in school other than what we’re doing now.”

Connie Ogle (Justice of the Peace 1&3): “Parent contributing to non-attendance is a criminal offense, truancy is civil, and you cannot compel a juvenile by state jail to tell you anything. If they don’t want to tell you why they didn’t go to school, you can’t compel them to. If you want to ask them why their mom did not take them to school, you can’t by state jail. My stand is you can tell them what can happen if found guilty of the truancy offense, but that’s about all you can do. Juveniles are protected and are a lot smarter than adults sometimes, and if they’re not going to tell you, they’re not going to tell you.”

Julie Sims (Justice of the Peace 1&3): “We have found ways for kids to make up for truancy hours such as D-Hall, but parents aren’t always aware of their kids missing school and why they’re missing school. I have brought them to the bench and asked them if they can tell me what’s going on, and most of them are pretty honest about it. We tell them they have to make up those hours so they can graduate. The school requires so many hours to graduate, and if they can make those hours up, they can graduate. I would like to continue with that because I’ve had lots of success with it.”

Jennifer Hart (Justice of the Peace 2&4): “As far as the truancy and parent contributing goes, I didn’t deal with a lot of that. The two JP offices split duties between them, but the Precinct 2&4 office, we don’t handle that side. So that’s something I don’t know a lot about and something I would have to look more into.”

Clifton Fletcher (Justice of the Peace 2&4): “That’s kind of hard to follow because everyone else has had experience with that. I’ve never had experience with truancy dealing with other kids or my own kids. I feel like you can get a relationship established with the kids and they feel like they can trust you, then they would let you know why they’re skipping out or whatever the reason. And then we can deal with that however the law allows us.”

Question #13 for all Justice of the Peace candidates:

How do you plan in handling landlord-tenant disputes?

Connie Ogle (Justice of the Peace 1&3): “The thing is landlord-tenants are not as big of a problem to me as squatters, but with the new law that went into effect in January, if you have a squatter in your home, used to you had to completely evict them, just like if this person was my kid and he made me mad, I would have to evict him to get him out of my house. You couldn’t just say get out. With the squatters, a landlord could go to a Constable or a Sheriff’s Deputy and say they have squatters and they want them gone and they would have to sign an affidavit and the Constable or the Deputy then takes it and gets a writ of possession and goes and says you’re out of here. So for a landlord-tenant, it’s tough to tell a family a week before Christmas they’ve got to leave the residence, and the law is the law, but you don’t have to be ugly about it.”

Julie Sims (Justice of the Peace 1&3): “We see evictions more than you realize, and each side gets a chance to speak and we just have to make our decision that’s based on the law. Like Connie said, the squatters file with the Constables and the Sheriffs and it makes it much easier. Our Constables do a lot for us.”

Jennifer Hartman (Justice of the Peace 2&4): “With landlord-tenants, when the defendant and plaintiff come into court, a lot of times they don’t know what to do and they’re very distraught. One thing we like to do is let each of them have their chance to speak, and the thing I’ve seen work in the courtroom is the plaintiff is able to talk and the defendant is able to tell their side, and sometimes they can work it out by setting up a payment plan, being able to stay in that house and working with each other. That’s one thing I like to see because they cannot leave saying they weren’t given the chance to give their side.”

Clifton Fletcher (Justice of the Peace 2&4): “What they said. Again, this is my first time getting into this stuff. I don’t really have knowledge about that, but me and my wife have had a rent house, luckily for the most part, people handled things the way they’re supposed to be done. But other than that, I don’t have any knowledge about it, and I’m willing to learn and do what I have to do. We just have to follow the law.”
Michael Lewis (Justice of the Peace 1&3): “Like Jennifer’s response, that’s pretty reasonable. I have a hard time knowing that there are certain people who own a lot of property and keep people moving from place to place, and I want to make sure that within the law that the tenant has their rights to be there, and at the same time the homeowner has their rights to kick them out. I just want to be able to balance that a little bit better and try to find a way to work things out. I’ve never been in court for that, but I would like to see it where they can work it out themselves and for their families, for both sides. I just want to make sure it’s fair and equal both ways.”

Question #14 for County Clerk candidates:

How do you handle confidentiality in the County Clerk’s office?

Candance Hanson: “Well we don’t talk about it. Confidentiality is very important, so we don’t talk about it even in the office. Especially if there’s someone in the office like a customer, we don’t talk about it.”

Dee Dee Laramore: “Confidentiality is one of the most important parts of our job. We have to sign an Oath of Confidentiality for the Texas Department of Health and Human Services because we handle vital records like birth certificates and death certificates. Those documents are very personal and very sensitive, so for us, it’s one of those things that are of highest importance. When we hire someone, that’s the first thing we say to them, that they recognize that they have to have a strong sense of confidentiality that you cannot be sharing information. Even with the things on our desks, when we leave at night, we have to be certain that those things are turned over and put away so the people cleaning our office or anyone who may accidently walk by won’t see something they’re not supposed to.”

Statement from John Browning, State Representative District 88:

“I would like to go back to the question that was asked-about a specific act that I’m not familiar with regarding the Wilks Brothers. I texted my comptroller and they have not personally nor through the PAC donated to my campaign. That being said, that question was posed probably by Mr. King’s camp, and I would like to pose this question: as you review the letters and the things that come to your mailbox, there on your return label is going to be who sent it. Who sent those? One of Ken King’s PACs that sends those letters out is the Texas Defense PAC who is funded mostly by Sams Casino out of Las Vegas. His big contributors are sending flyers on his behalf and as well as mine, many of which I’m not familiar with. For those reasons, I ask you to do your due diligence, and I ask you when you look at me as a candidate, look at my heart. I post 88 seconds on my Facebook page, I also speak blessings over Ken and his family and his kin. They are setting traps that they want me to make mistakes. I ask you to vote for my heart.”